Should I Repair or Replace My Roof?

Roof Repairs vs. Replacement: How to Choose the Right Solution for Your Home

When your roof has a problem — whether it’s a leak, missing shingles, or storm damage — you’re faced with a big question:
Should I repair it, or is it time to replace the whole thing?

At Bo Lacey Construction, we’ve worked on thousands of roofs across Mansfield, Norwalk, Mount Vernon, Columbus, and nearby communities. Here’s how we help you decide the best path forward for your home, budget, and long-term peace of mind.

When Is a Roof Repair Enough?

Roof repairs can be a great option when:

• Damage is isolated (like a small area hit by a falling branch)
• The roof is fairly new and in otherwise solid condition
• Shingles are still pliable and available in the same color/style

In these cases, we can restore your roof’s strength and seal without the cost of a full replacement.

Why Roof Age Really Matters

The older your roof, the trickier repairs become. Over time, shingles lose their flexibility, making them prone to cracking when lifted or nailed. And if the original shingles are discontinued, patchwork repairs can leave visible mismatches.

That’s bad for curb appeal—and it could even impact resale value or trigger insurance replacement requirements.

Common Issues We Find on Aging Roofs

Sadly, most roofs weren’t installed correctly the first time. In fact, we see these issues all the time:

• 🔥 Shingles curling from attic heat buildup (poor ventilation)
• 💨 Shingles blowing off from bad nailing or low-grade products
• ⛏️ Nail pops causing small leaks
• 🌧️ Improper chimney or wall flashing leading to water damage or mold

If your roof has these problems, a repair might just delay the inevitable.

Why We Often Recommend Full-Plane Replacements

Even when a repair seems possible, we frequently recommend replacing the entire slope (or “plane”) of the roof instead of a tiny patch. Here’s why:

• ✅ Uniform Appearance – No weird checkerboard look
• 🎨 Better Color Match – Avoids visual mismatch with older shingles
• 🛡️ Improved Function – We can upgrade ventilation, flashings, and underlayment in that section

Same Premium Materials—No Matter the Job

Whether it’s a minor repair or a full roof replacement, Bo Lacey Construction uses the same certified process and high-performance materials on every job.

That means:

• Warranty-backed installations
• Industry-best flashing and underlayment
• Expert crews who care about every detail

You’ll get work that lasts—and looks great doing it.

Limited-Time Offer ($399 Value – Free)

For a limited time, we’re offering homeowners:

• ✅ Full roof inspection
• ✅ Photo documentation of any damage
• ✅ 3D rendering and professional design consultation

(Value: $399 — yours free when you schedule today!)